Carol Overland - Legalectric
Buy the Farm bolstered, at long last
WOW, what a long strange trip this has been. I’ve been on this since Chisago I (1996) and Arrowhead:
Arrowhead was exempted, and hence Buy the Farm doesn’t apply, so that went to the Appellate Court, which tossed it out. And the 2001 statutory changes, which defined “high voltage transmission lines” as anything over 100 kV, meaning Buy the Farm would apply to 115 kV lines like SE Metro, and Chisago, but nooooo, can’t have that, so Sen. Metzen then amended in 2002 so that it only applies to lines 200 kV or over. GRRRRRRRRRRRR.
Here’s the update in the Belle Plaine Herald (why is there nothing whatsoever in the STrib?). GRE’s Randy Fordice claims it’s vaguely worded, but I think it’s pretty specific:
All rights and protections provided to an owner under chapter 117 apply to acquisition of land or an interest in land under this section.
DOH! Vague my ass…
Legislature OKs Amendment to ‘Buy the Farm’ Law
“We’ll see if it helps people the way they want it to. I hope it does,” Woodard said.
“The clock is the biggest challenge, not the votes,” Dahle said.
Our neighbor Lake has died…
It’s a sad day in Red Wing and in Port Penn this morning. Our neighbor Lake, who I’ve known since he was six months old, has died.
When I met him, I was down in the street in front of the house, and he and his human, Barry, came trotting down the street. He was just a pup, and at 6 months was the size of my Katze, a year and a half old shepherd, and he was 20 pounds heavier already! He was your typical lab pup, full of energy. He and Katze would leap up the two retaining walls up to the house, run behind the house and around a few times, jump down, and repeat, and repeat, and repeat. You could hear their peals of laughter and joy in being dogs. Did I mention he was full of energy? My other dogs weren’t as good to him, frankly, they were bitches, but Lake, lab that he is, was a gentleman always.
When I’d visit the Moens, he’d always cozy up to me, maybe smelling the treats in my pocket, or maybe just enjoying my “Eau de Shep,” and his BIG head would always rest on my knee, trusting. He was the kind of dog you couldn’t resist hugging, who would make a good bedwarmer on a cold Minnesota night.
Poor dear didn’t do too well when I took care of him not that long ago, he drank and drank and made himself sick, WOW, his belly held a lot!!! He recovered quickly, ready to eat more, OK, fine, Lake, but no more water!!!!
He’d been visibly slowing down, trudging along 8th Street, not wanting to run up the bluff, and recently it got to where he couldn’t do stairs (see photo, that’s a real problem) or go for walks. Then he quit eating, where even beef and rice had no appeal. The photo of him was his last morning, surveying his kingdom in Red Wing.
Lake, we’ll miss you, good neighbor!!! Give my regards to our grrrrrrrrrrls Katze, Krie, Kenya and Summer who are there to meet you and show you the ropes… and bones, and venison steaks, and running paths!
Whew! Linda & Matt did it — wedding’s done!
Got to Delaware just in time — Matt and Linda got married today. As Alan says, it’s good they can be together for 18 years and still want to get married! THEY DID IT!
They’re my favorite people in Delaware, well, except for Alan of course, and Matt’s mother makes pizelles to die for! Matt and Linda run DelPizzo Construction:
Linda and Matt are both are active environmentalists, Matt has been a primary part of Delaware Audubon for ages and they did the heavy lifting last year when Audubon gave Alan its environmental award. Linda has amazing artistic talents, making Alan a beautiful 6 foot bright blue sequin fish costume for a hearing, and for a demonstration in Dover, flat black cut-outs, a water buffalo/pig (?) representing former Gov. Minner connected by chains and led around by the nose by a big bankster! That’s Matt in the tan fish outfit at the Delaware AudubonFest:
As weddings go, it was as good as it gets (well, I’m not a big fan, don’t cha know), haven’t been to a wedding in SO long… and, well, I’ve got an aversion to this day, May 18 is my anniversary, 39 years ago — I told Linda about that and she noted that she was 6 months old then. SAY WHAT! Whoa, talk about feeling like an old fart, we’re as old as their parents — I had no idea! Anyway, for them, and to get some long overdue work done in DE, we hit the road. It was in historic Odessa, Delaware, at the Corbit-Sharp House, really a complex of historic houses and a great barn for serving. Appetizers (veggies, fruit, cheeze, bread) and sufficient ETOH to be lubricated prior to the show, a short and sweet ceremony, and on to dinner, mostly vegan, PIZELLES and the Rock Fish with Chimichurri Sauce, oh so good, the Cantwell’s Tavern did the food. And PIZELLES! Vegan wedding cake of carrot and pineapple (coconut and ??? frosting, maybe soy milk or soy cream cheeze?). Have to admit, I skipped the cigar bar… and did I mention PIZELLES???!!!???
A few weeks ago when Matt was in Minnesota on an Anderson Windows junket, we corralled him for dinner, he sacrificed a tour in the pole-dancer bus, and it was clear how much he was missing Linda (well, that’s Alan and my guess anyway), they’re one of the few couples I know who are a joy to be around together. So after 18 years, here they go, married – ’bout time!
CONGRATULATIONS, Matt & Linda!
Goodhue Wind winds down… slowly…
A little birdie tells me that my site is a snooze.
That’s true. I’ve been getting some domestic projects done that I’ve been ignoring, and I’ve started a big project that requires lots of research… zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz… believe me, that’s more of a snooze than my blog, and I hope worth the wait.
So what else is happening?
The Goodhue Wind project was taken off the May 2 Public Utilities Commission agenda and “temporarily” rescheduled for June 20, 2013. But there’s a new filing provided by Xcel Energy that got me snortin’ recently, dig this:
Letter – Xcel Energy – May 8, 2013
And no hints – you’ve got to read the whole thing. Peter Mastic is more than a little bruised after this letter!
2012 NERC Long Term Reliability Assessment
The North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC) released its 2012 Long Term Reliability Assessment last November. This rates a BIG SIGH, I have yet to post it. How can that be? Well, November was a hectic time, to put it mildly, but then I look and it’s the same thing last year. Anyway, here we go!
2012_NERC LONG TERM RELIABILITY ASSESSMENT_FINAL
And in case you missed it:
2011 NERC LONG TERM RELIABILITY ASSESSMENT
Now, as to some of the specifics in the 2012 Reliability Assessment. I was recently asked about “wind replacing coal” which is a popular fallacy, because it doesn’t replace coal, not physically, not electrically, not legally, no way, no how.
From the NERC 2012 Long Term Reliability Assessment, p. 103-104 (click for larger version):
And NERC Report p. 107 – Retiring coal plants are the old small ones (divide the MW by units)
When you’re hearing people crowing about less coal generation, about using less coal, and about generating less CO2, that’s all because there’s less demand, they’re not needing the old, expensive smaller coal plants to meet demand.
Another view of retirements –dispatch is on “economic” basis, meaning cheapest first. That means big coal. The old small coal plants are very costly to run and usually don’t. What this means is that they can shut down the small inefficient and uneconomic plants without suffering because they don’t need them for demand, and they’re high priced to operate and usually sit idle anyway. Now that natural gas is so cheap, it also means natural gas, although in Midwest, they don’t use gas for baseload, as they do on east coast. So the gas here is peaking power, and is usually more expensive because it’s owned by IPP and under Power Purchase Agreements for peaking (high price). Though Xcel owns its own gas now, remember it repowered a couple old coal plants, and they probably could use that more often and don’t have to pay the higher prices of peaking PPAs. See Retirements, NERC Report, p. 8 of 335:
And remember, not one Renewable Energy Standard “replaces” anything. It is a mandate to generate more electricity ON TOP OF the surplus. And the mandate is needed because there is no market. It’s adding surplus to surplus. Not one RES in the nation says “generation X MW of renewable and decrease fossil by X or X-Y or ?.” There is no replacement intended or accomplished. Further unlike solar, wind is off peak, when they’re doing their market transactions, selling all the coal they can. How much can they sell? Well, it’s not reported in the MISO section of the NERC report, which states that only internal transactions MISO are reported (again, click for larger view):
Anyway, bottom line is that reserve margins are twice what they need to be (click chart for the big picture):
100 mile garage sale — and storm cleanup
Today begins a holiday weekend in SE Minnesota, well, it started yesterday, but so did the snow, so we’re getting a late start.
100 mile garage sale!Clean up started in earnest today, they had a bucket truck, bobcat and pick up, and I woke up to a chorus of chain saws.
The office is CLOSED today!
May 2nd? Foot+ of snow, tree down blocking street, power out
Need I say more? Well, there is more coming down, it’s snowing steadily…
Guy from City just came through with a front end loader and rammed into the tree and ripped it apart and plowed it over to the side:
What a mess. Once they get a plow through, snow seems to melt and it’s passable, but all over the walks and yards, it’s just sitting there. Nobody is moving. Mailman was climbing around the tree limbs, they’re everywhere. If I could get out, I’d seriously consider heading to Costa Rica. This is absurd.
Respect for the Earth and its residents
They did change the headline, but the Red Wing Republican Eagle (“the Beagle”) printed my Commentary on Wednesday (the same day that the Public Utilities Commission postponed the Goodhue Wind May 2nd agenda item until June 20th!):
Commentary: Respect blows strong for Earth and citizensBy: Carol Overland, The Republican Eagle
Why pull the plug? The project has fallen apart.
The Public Utilities Commission has asked reasonable questions, and New Era has not answered.
Wind must be sited correctly, because turbines aren’t easily moved.
This is Earth Day. It’s not about “being right” but about “getting it right.”
Carol A. Overland of Red Wing is the attorney for Goodhue Wind Truth.
Mesaba Project loses MISO queue G519
I love it when this happens, it’s almost as good as the results of a google image search for “Excelsior yahoos” this morning:
Big thanks to a little birdie who relayed the good news:
hee hee hee hee hee, I LOVE it when this happens…







